It is currently February 23rd 2018 5:01 pm

Post Posted: December 28th 2017 1:21 pm

Join: October 15th 2014 8:24 pm
Posts: 37
So at this point it's pretty clear that Ben is the last remaining member of Anakin's family-tree and that things aren't really looking too good for the Skywalker line in terms of legacy or future generations.

Do any of you foresee any other outcome for Ben in Episode IX besides death? Is there any possible way the character can be redeemed and survive or is his death assured?

If his death is a foregone conclusion, how do you feel about the Skywalker line ending (technically it already has since he's a Solo, but you know what I mean).

Post Posted: December 29th 2017 1:09 am
User avatar

Join: May 2nd 2005 7:26 am
Posts: 1999
Location: Down the rabbit hole
Kathleen has previously stated that EPIX is the end of the skywalker saga....sounds like the story is already written.

Post Posted: December 29th 2017 1:18 am

Join: December 24th 2004 6:14 pm
Posts: 79
I took numerous university courses on ancient near-Eastern and classical history. I was even beckoned to go on an archaeological dig in Egypt, which I was very sadly far too poor to pay for. I mention this so that the weight of what I'm about to state can be measured...

As far as I know, there has never been a myth where patricide does not end with the murderer's death or the delivery of a consequence so severe, it's akin to death; that is, an enormously robust transformation.

The murderous child of his father has NO ESCAPE from the consequences. Again, as far as I know (and I've studied world mythologies a lot), patricide always equals a death to the murdering child.

That's probably a big reason why Lucas refused to have Luke kill his father. Lucas was enamored with thousands of years' worth of human wisdom encapsulated in The Hero's Journey. I have no doubts that Lucas would've had a very hard time with allowing Luke to escape a fate from a schema that Lucas was deeply steeped in. Lucas, in fact, has stated this himself. This is a nearly perfect quote of what he said in an interview, "The father is redeemed in his older years by his younger son. It's a cycle..." There can be no redemption of the father if the son has murdered him, and thus the severe consequences for a child who slays his/her father.

All of that said, what Lucasfilm/Disney will do with Ben is anyone's guess. Via The Last Jedi, they deliberately and totally smashed The Hero's Journey on its head, dashing its brains out. For evidence of this, reference my Reply to an earlier posted question on this topic here:

Will Ben be redeemed? If we're following the central repeating mythical tenets of numerous culture's around the planet, he shouldn't be.

A more interesting question, to me, anyway, is would Luke have given up on him? Based on never giving up on his sociopath-butcher and mass-enslaving father, the answer should've been a resounding "No." Luke would never have given up on Ben, a family member that he not only knew far better than his father, but who he also literally raised and nurtured.

Luke might very well pester Ben in the next film, being that Ben has no conscious Luke will be it for him.

From what I've read, the Skywalkers will all be dead by the end of Episode IX. I think that the odds are overwhelming that Ben will die, but will be it be as a pure monster or in some final Last Gasp redemptive act is yet to be seen. It's very challenging for me to imagine a way that his end could somehow be redemptive in nature. The last Skywalker will very likely be of a very black heart.

As can be found in my previous posts, I was excited to see Skywalker-free Star Wars movies, but after the train wreck of The Last Jedi, I'm completely disenchanted as to where Abrams/Kennedy/Johnson/Hidalgo are going to steer this hearse.

Post Posted: December 29th 2017 11:35 am

Join: December 24th 2015 5:26 am
Posts: 179
So whilst I imagine Disney want to open up the Star Wars universe in order to have, for example, Captain Phasma fighting Doctor Strange, I suspect Disney will never move that far away from the Skywalker clan. They haven’t even got the imagination to move away from stormtroopers and Death Star’s let alone Darth Vader/Anakin Skywalker and Luke. I can’t blame them for wanting to hold onto such strong cinematic iconography as Vader’s mask and X-Wings, but boy is it lacking in creative intelligence at the moment... in my opinion of course.

Post Posted: December 29th 2017 11:50 am

Join: November 16th 2008 3:10 pm
Posts: 273
...but, big ass slow bombers! that crumble, and have to "drop" a payload in space...

Post Posted: December 29th 2017 12:52 pm
User avatar

Join: August 25th 2004 12:31 pm
Posts: 3365
I'd love to see him get killed and not be redeemed. Like Macbeth or Richard III. Just kill the fucking bastard. :jango: :funkyvflamethrower:

Post Posted: December 29th 2017 3:24 pm

Join: December 24th 2015 5:26 am
Posts: 179
Even now, I still think there’s opportunity to end the ST on a high by perhaps ending it with Rey joining the darkside and Kylo being redeemed etc. etc. But the OT characters are already fu**ed in my opinion.

Post Posted: December 31st 2017 9:59 am

Join: March 15th 2004 8:56 pm
Posts: 160
Location: LA
I’ve been expecting that he’ll be badly injured and put in a suit just for the sake of irony.

Post Posted: December 31st 2017 1:03 pm
User avatar

Title: MeMyself&I
Join: October 13th 2014 7:15 pm
Posts: 21
Location: Outer Rim
I still believe Rey is related to Kenobi.
And this is why they are holding off announcing the Kenobi stand alone film to add the element of surprise.
The reveal of this heritage in IX will drive interest into the Kenobi Film. She might even be part Mandalorian.

I am leaning towards Kylo being redeemed by Rey and you will again have a Skywalker and Kenobi defending the galaxy ala The Clone Wars.
Rey will do for a Skywalker (Kylo) what Obi-Wan could not do for Anakin (redeem him).
This ties-in/raps up/brings full circle the sequel trilogy along with I-VI as Abrams stated it would.
I think they will leave the door open to X-XII but it will be ten years from now and Rey and Kylo will defend the galaxy from an outside force.
They will re-introduce/reboot the Vong and that will be the unifying event that will bring the Empire/First Order and the Rebellion/Republic together.
A new, symbiotic relationship like Qui-Gon & Obi-Wan talk about in TPM.

The Skywalker saga will end after XII.

Post Posted: January 1st 2018 7:11 pm
User avatar

Join: August 4th 2004 8:00 pm
Posts: 1091
Prior to watching TLJ, I would be open to theories about Kenobi lineage. However, that seems to be old-world Star Wars theorizing. In turn, it seems to be too conventional a surprise for the sequel to TLJ.

I do think that there are twists to be had with Rey. The mirror sequence led me to believe that the now debunked reincarnation angle was being followed. Rey being a reincarnation of a Choose One or the First Jedi would add weight to Yoda's comment about her already knowing everything in the Jedi text. So, there's an opening if Abrams wants to go this direction.

If Rey's past requires further discussion, I would hope that Force ghost Luke would do the explaining a la Sir Alec's Obi-wan in ROTJ. For me, such a scene would help to take the sting out of Luke's surprising character arc in TLJ.

Post Posted: January 2nd 2018 1:54 pm

Join: October 15th 2014 8:24 pm
Posts: 37
I interpreted Rey's cave moment as being a message that she should not worry about who her parents are, and that it's more important that she focus on her own journey.

I think Kyle's points are spot on - patricides are always, always punished somehow, with their death usually being a foregone conclusion.

I can only see two ways that the Skywalker line continues post Episode 9:

1) Kylo gets quickly redeemed, gets it on with Rey, and then shortly thereafter dies somehow.
2) The old fan-theory that it was Han himself who activated Kylo's lightsaber ends up being true.

Option 2 would be tough to pull off but not utterly impossible, and would be a pretty huge reveal for Episode 9.

Option 1 seems to be the only other logical way to get themselves out of the corner they've put themselves in.

This is all assuming that they would actually want to keep the Skywalker line going though. With 40 years of marketing and world-wide brand recognition on par with Coca-Cola, I personally feel that it would be insane for Disney to put a knife through it (and would make their shareholders scream bloody murder), but after the Last Jedi I'm realizing that Disney and Kennedy don't actually seem all that invested in the Skywalkers and that all bets are off when it comes to where they are planning to take this franchise.

Post Posted: January 3rd 2018 7:44 am
User avatar

Join: August 25th 2004 12:31 pm
Posts: 3365
I thought it was stated by Lucas himself back in 2012 that Episodes 7, 8 and 9 would mark the end of the Skywalker's story.

Post Posted: January 3rd 2018 9:11 am
User avatar

Join: May 2nd 2005 7:26 am
Posts: 1999
Location: Down the rabbit hole
George's original plan, back in the day, was for 12 films....he later dialed it back, but I think, knowing George, he like would have made all 12. See the article below: ... -republic/

Post Posted: January 4th 2018 7:03 am
User avatar

Join: January 23rd 2005 8:45 am
Posts: 11
Location: Adelaide, Australia
Cryostar wrote:
George's original plan, back in the day, was for 12 films....he later dialed it back, but I think, knowing George, he like would have made all 12. See the article below: ... -republic/

Timothy Zahn wrote:
But one of the things I’d really like to see, and this would fit very nicely with Disney, as far as I can remember we’ve never seen a really good family relationship in Star Wars. We’ve had neurotic relationships and even outright antagonism with Luke and Vader. But I’d like to see Luke and his son or grandson have a true bond, a functional family relationship.

Post Posted: February 4th 2018 6:34 am

Join: December 30th 2004 7:13 am
Posts: 220
Reading this Thread, i'd agree that there's more than likely a comeuppance for Kylo/Ben.

Some oddities that have floated through the brain pan how this Saga could end/continue, that i'd like to share ...

A Corny idea, but what if Rey's a Clone of Luke ? The Cave sequence on TLJ could be symbolic of such a notion.

That could keep the Skywalker bloodline as a continuing thread and there would be a Familial opposite to Ben Solo.

Also, aside from New Order vs Resistance/Rebels what if another faction comes into play ? A conglomeration
of organised Pirates/Ne'erdowells and the like (maybe with their own Force sensitives in the mix)

A one legged Boba Fett thrown in with a couple of Mandalorian garbed acolytes led by a Sith Witch at their
core perhaps. Their fleet a rag tag selection of old and new craft (Trade federation craft pimped with
Smuggler tech/ re-purposed iconic vehicles with new shapes)

A threat so ambiguous to the old contrasts of Goody Vs Baddy that the status quo is redifined to such an
extent, that Kylo Ren is good by comparison.

An opportunity for an about turn for the unredeemable.

What if Snoke was Palpatine was Plagueis was whoever came before?

Darth Sidious in episode III, the scene of Anakins inauguration the wheezy discordance.

A vessel possessed by spirits passed ?

A Ghostly puppetmaster with vast riches stashed, who returns in gnarled forms (Darksides toll)

The power of foreseeing, ragged tattered visions of futures untold. The Plagueis paradox ability to
bring into being via the Midi Chlorian manipulations of sentients biology, new Force gifted life.

That only the strongest subjects survive, seeding the universe with chaos.

The puppetmaster as an eternal nemesis throughout the generations.

A new face for a new Trilogy.

Post Posted: February 4th 2018 9:07 am
User avatar

Join: January 4th 2009 3:49 am
Posts: 142
Location: Brisbane
It's all such a clusterf**k now that I am really finding it hard to be interested in what they do.

Post Posted: February 4th 2018 4:02 pm

Join: January 31st 2005 11:58 pm
Posts: 565
Location: Australia
I still can't get over the fact that they're writing this trilogy as they go.

Post Posted: February 5th 2018 7:48 am
User avatar

Join: August 25th 2004 12:31 pm
Posts: 3365
Mike_Droideka wrote:
I still can't get over the fact that they're writing this trilogy as they go.

How is that much different from the original trilogy?

Post Posted: February 8th 2018 12:22 pm
User avatar

Join: October 12th 2004 9:34 pm
Posts: 2518
Location: Toronto, Canada
It's not. Believing that George had a grand plan for the OT is revisionist.

Post Posted: February 21st 2018 10:22 am

Join: April 24th 2005 2:00 pm
Posts: 136
Lucas didn't know if he would even be allowed to make a sequel. Disney doesn't have this excuse. They also don't have a benefit of one main storyteller to provide at least some semblance of consistency. They didn't even have EU stories since they discarded them. Certainly Star Wars (1977) provided enough information about Luke and the universe he inhabited to make for a satisfying coming of age story. By contrast, Abrams admitted he didn't have a clue about Rey's origins and left it to Johnson to decide. That's storytelling 101. I'm sure he didn't know about why Ben fell to the dark side or how the New Republic (the former Rebels) allowed a much bigger Death Star to be built or why Luke was behaving like a coward. He just set up his idiotic mystery box hoping someone else would untangle it.

Post Posted: February 21st 2018 2:48 pm
User avatar

Join: October 12th 2004 9:34 pm
Posts: 2518
Location: Toronto, Canada
So what was the excuse for Leia being the other or the second Death Star? Isn’t that also “lazy storytelling?”

Post Posted: February 21st 2018 10:56 pm

Join: April 24th 2005 2:00 pm
Posts: 136
No one is saying all Lucas's ideas worked out great but there's usually a reasoning behind his decisions (i.e. Leia became a sister because he felt he didn't have time to introduce a new character), another Death Star happened because he couldn't do two Death Stars and an Imperial City (at least DSII was used in a different way from ANH). Despite all that the OT is still way more consistent and doesn't rely on the outside sources to explain the basic world building or character development. You can't blame the fans for coming up with all sorts of theories to explain Rey's super powers so different from what came before (ironically, most of them were better than the final product).

Post Posted: February 22nd 2018 11:37 pm
User avatar

Join: October 12th 2004 9:34 pm
Posts: 2518
Location: Toronto, Canada
I don't really understand your point, though. Is your argument that it's OK for ROTJ to have undercooked or repetitive elements because it was still the product of a single creative vision? I don't care what Lucas' reasoning is, it doesn't stop those beats from being less successful aspects to the OT. We overlook that because, well, we love those movies.

Empire Strikes Back is my favourite movie of all time, but that doesn't mean that there aren't several leaps of faith the audience has to make for that movie to work. How did Luke go from clumsily waving a lightsaber at a wompa to skilled swordsman who can take on Vader in just a few days? Why did the Empire deactivate the hyperdrive on the Falcon rather than just blowing up the ship? How did Luke know that he could communicate telepathically with Leia? Where did he learn that Force power? So yes, I also want to know why Rey is so skilled (I think we got the hint of an explanation in TLJ with Snoke's line "darkness rises, and light to meet it") but let's not pretend that Luke didn't get real good real fast.

Ultimately, I don't care how many cooks are in the kitchen as long as the story beats pay off. I was irritated by Starkiller Base as much as it sounds like you were, and I thought the second half of TFA was worse for it, but I did think that the characters were great and there was enough set up for the story to go in a bunch of interesting directions. All I care about is for the ST to feel necessary, and finish the tale of the Skywalker family. I hope Episode 9 fulfills that.

Display posts from previous:  Sort by  

Jump to:©