Joe1138 wrote:I don't think it's fair to write Kasdan off after one failure.
I agree. If anything, he has proven he understands the SW world but can deal with it objectively.
It would be too easy to bring in people who are Star Wars/Sci-Fi "fans", but Kasdan is the kind of guy who seems to wring out the real-world touches that these things so desparately need.
Personally, I still think that the best thing that can happen is that people who are grounded
outside of the sci-fi/fantasy genre are involved. I suppose Kasdan is famous for Empire and Raiders, but it always seemed to me his task was to take all the sci-fi stuff that was already there and make it more human. Develop the characters and bring out the drama.
I don't really approve of most of the names that are being thrown around as directors to be honest.
It seems like anyone who has made a sci-fi/comic book movie in the past 10 years is under consideration. I'd much rather someone was chosen on the basis of them being able to make good, thought-provoking films rather than them having landed a box office success within the genre.
Of course, that could lead to an Ang Lee's Hulk scenario, but I'd still rather see them take that gamble than churn out another identikit sci-fi movie with SW branding.